I watched a company keep talking about record bookings while revenue growth slowed. At times, revenue missed management's own forecast. The CEO saw the record bookings commentary as evidence that the business was doing well. Investors couldn't reconcile it with the results they were getting.
The company didn't disclose bookings. It also hadn't given investors a usable way to connect the record to future revenue. So the positive description couldn't do the work management was asking it to do.
That's the problem with a lot of public-company disclosure. The language sounds informative to management because it knows the numbers behind the description. But the investor still needs those missing inputs to calculate what the commentary means for revenue. An adjective on its own doesn't give him that.
The missing calculation
“Record” says a number exceeded its prior high. It doesn't tell you how quickly that number is growing or when it will contribute to revenue. A growing company can set a new record while its growth rate slows.
There may be a perfectly reasonable explanation for bookings and revenue moving differently. Contract duration or the timing of a deployment could affect the relationship. Those are possibilities an investor needs to evaluate, not explanations he should have to invent for management.
If bookings are part of the investment argument, explain how investors should use them. Otherwise the company is asking people to accept a favorable conclusion without giving them the inputs behind it.
When the reported revenue keeps disappointing, that request becomes harder to accept. Repeating the positive language doesn't fix the missing connection.
A percentage can have the same problem
I've seen companies disclose that a product was 20% of enterprise revenue without disclosing enterprise's share of the total company. Management thought it had supplied useful information. Investors knew the product was 20% of an unknown number.
Consider a hypothetical company. If enterprise represents 25% of total revenue, that product represents 5% of the company. If enterprise represents 75%, the product represents 15%. The same percentage can describe very different levels of exposure.
You can't assess how much a product's growth could change total revenue without knowing roughly how much of the company that product represents. So the precise percentage doesn't solve the investor's problem. Management has left out another input he needs to finish the calculation.
This is easy for management to overlook because everyone in the preparation meeting knows the denominator and can finish the calculation in their heads. But the investor doesn't have access to the same information. He's still working with the bits and pieces management has made public.
Test the information from outside
Before the earnings release goes out, have someone work through the important claims using only public information. Don't let them use the internal operating model to fill the gaps.
Can they connect the metric to the financial result? Can they compare it with the prior period? Do they know what changed because the business changed and what changed because the definition changed?
If they can't, decide whether the disclosure needs an additional input or whether it shouldn't carry so much weight in the story. You don't have to publish every operating metric. But the ones you choose should be useful enough to justify investors' attention.
There can be good reasons not to disclose a number. That doesn't make an incomplete percentage a substitute for it. Be clear about what the public information can support, and don't imply a level of financial visibility it doesn't provide.
I'd also resist solving this by adding more pages to the presentation. A missing denominator or a clearer explanation of timing may do more than several new charts.
Before approving the disclosure, ask whether it lets an investor build a more defensible forecast. If he's still guessing at the same business driver, you've added information without resolving the uncertainty that may be keeping him from owning more of your stock.
